Shimano S-Phyre Overschoenen vs Vaude Luminum Vest
Comparison 2026 — Cycling Clothing
VS
Our verdict
Based on our weighted scoring, the Shimano S-Phyre Overschoenen edges out the Vaude Luminum Vest with an overall score of 77/100 against 75/100. It scores particularly well on waterproofing (92/100) and breathability (74/100), making it the better all-round pick in Cycling Clothing.
The Vaude Luminum Vest remains a sensible alternative if price is your main concern — it lands at €60.00 versus €55.00.
Waterproofing winner
Shimano S-Phyre Overschoenen
32% higher than its rival
Value winner
Vaude Luminum Vest
4% better value for money
Specifications
| Specification | Shimano S-Phyre Overschoenen | Vaude Luminum Vest |
|---|---|---|
| Price | €55.00+9% | €60.00 |
| Rating | ★4.4 (920) | ★4.2 (680) |
| Overall | 77/100+3% | 75/100 |
| Materials | ||
| Water column | 15.000 mm+400% | 3.000 mm (DWR) |
| Breathability | 7.000 g/m²/24h | 10.000 g/m²/24h+43% |
| Seams | Volledig getapet | — |
| Weight | 140 g (per paar)+18% | 165 g |
| Standard | — | EN 20471 klasse 2 |
| Sizing | ||
| Sizes | S (36-40) t/m XXL (47-49) | S t/m XXL |
| Shoe type | Road/Gravel clipless | — |
| Fit | — | Over-shirt, regular |
Pros and cons
Shimano S-Phyre Overschoenen
Pros
- 15,000 mm water column — rated for extreme autumn conditions
- Fully taped seams — no leaks in sustained rain
- Aerodynamic fit for road and gravel shoes
- Rear reflective accents for traffic visibility
Cons
- Only fits clipless road and gravel shoes, not city shoes
- Rear zipper wears faster than the fabric itself
Vaude Luminum Vest
Pros
- EN 20471 class 2 — visible up to 300 metres in car headlights
- Windproof front against chill at 0-10°C
- Compacts down for an office backpack
- 3M Scotchlite reflective bands wrapping the torso
Cons
- Not fully waterproof — DWR wears off after 20-30 washes
- Bright yellow isn't everyone's look for the office