Basil City Shopper vs Brooks Brick Lane Panniers
Comparison 2026 — Bike Bags
Reviewed by Emma Bakker
Urban Cycling & Family Editor
VS
Our verdict
Based on our weighted scoring, the Brooks Brick Lane Panniers edges out the Basil City Shopper with an overall score of 70/100 against 68/100. It scores particularly well on waterproofing (56/100) and capacity (60/100), making it the better all-round pick in Bike Bags.
The Basil City Shopper remains a sensible alternative if price is your main concern — it lands at €39.95 versus €165.00.
Waterproofing winner
Brooks Brick Lane Panniers
6% higher than its rival
Value winner
Basil City Shopper
28% better value for money
Specifications
| Specification | Basil City Shopper | Brooks Brick Lane Panniers |
|---|---|---|
| Price | €39.95+313% | €165.00 |
| Rating | ★4.2 (1,680) | ★4.3 (340) |
| Overall | 68/100 | 70/100+3% |
| Capacity | ||
| Volume | 16 L+33% | 12 L per tas |
| Dimensions | 35 × 31 × 15 cm | 37 × 32 × 12 cm+6% |
| Material | ||
| Main material | Polyester dubbelwandig | Waterafstotend katoen, leren accenten |
| Waterproof | Nee (waterafstotend) | Nee (waterafstotend) |
| Weight | 500 g+50% | 750 g per tas |
| Mount | ||
| System | Haken voor bagagedrager | — |
Pros and cons
Basil City Shopper
Pros
- Double-walled design keeps the bag open for easy loading
- Budget price — the cheapest decent bike bag in this list
- Universal hooks fit almost any rear rack
- Reflective details for visibility in the dark
Cons
- Not waterproof — you'll need a rain cover when it pours
- Hooks are basic, nowhere near as solid as Ortlieb's QL2.1
Brooks Brick Lane Panniers
Pros
- Gorgeous Brooks aesthetic with natural cotton and leather detailing
- Waxed cotton patinates beautifully with use
- Universal hooks fit most rear racks
- Shoulder strap included for use as a shoulder bag
Cons
- Not fully waterproof — in heavy rain moisture gets through
- The most expensive option, with less volume than Ortlieb or Vaude
Where to buy
Basil City Shopper
Amazon.nl
€39.95Shop on Amazon.nl
Brooks Brick Lane Panniers
Amazon.nl
€165.00Shop on Amazon.nl
If you buy through this link, we earn a small commission. This doesn't influence our scores.